Melody Ellison: American Girl – 3 Messages You Missed

messages you missed

I have a confession. I purposefully keep my girls from getting involved in the American Girl craze. There are several reasons I could offer to explain myself, but I won’t make excuses. I love the brand, the empowerment it offers girls, and the history lessons it teaches. But can I be honest for a moment? The dolls are expensive and there aren’t very many dolls of color.  I need to be able to leverage all the brand had to offer – books, films, online interactives, AND the doll – in order to invest that amount. OK, maybe I am being cheap. Sue me.

But the release of the newest character from American Girl changed my outlook. The story of Melody Ellison, a young African American girl growing up in Detroit during the heart of the Civil Rights Movement is the perfect way to help me teach my 9 and 11-year-old daughters what it means to be black in America.

Also Related: American Girl Story – Melody 1963: Love Has to Win + Melody Review

My family was super excited to watch the Melody 1963: Love Has To Win on Amazon Video. It’s a story of perseverance, hard work, and disappointment, but most of all it’s a story of hope. We watched it together and had a short discussion about what we learned and how it affects our lives in the present.

The thing I loved most about the way Melody 1963 was told on screen are the subtle messages woven throughout the story. They are hidden in plain sight. So obvious, that my family overlooked most of them, and I bet you did too.

Also Related: Teach Your Girls to Love their Curls with #BeCurlCentric Coloring Book

Messages You Missed: Frances Ellison was well educated

By day Frances Ellison worked in the textile industry taking inventory to make a living. By night, she played the piano in her home – beautifully. For some, playing a musical instrument is a gift; they can mimic what they’ve heard on the keys. What Frances possessed was a skill; one that she had to work hard to hone. She wasn’t just playing any music. She was playing classical concertos. Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart. And she wasn’t playing by ear either. She was reading the music, line by line, and note by note. She was taught to read music and play piano as a young African American woman probably in the 1940s or 50s. And she taught her daughter as well. Melody could not have been her mother’s page turner if she could not read music.

Messages You Missed: Melody went to an all-white school in Detroit

If you believed everything you hear on the news, you would think that the only people who ever lived in Detroit were African American. But here, in the middle of the Civil Rights Era, Melody attends an all-white school in Detroit. One that her mother worked hard to get her into so she could excel academically. It was just three years prior that another little girl walked through doors of an all-white school in New Orleans. Her name was Ruby Bridges. Even though “separate but equal” had been ruled unconstitutional nearly 10 years earlier, it was still practiced in many places. Including the school in Melody’s neighborhood. That wasn’t acceptable for Frances, even with the emotional stress it placed on Melody. In her mind, the benefits outweighed the challenges.

Messages You Missed: Melody is being raised by a single mother

The Ellison home consists of Melody, her mother Frances, and her grandfather Frank. Melody’s father is not there. He died, serving his country in the military. Set during the Civil Rights Movement Era, many people sacrificed their lives and safety fighting for equal rights. In a moment of social consciousness Melody questions the validity of the words “one nation, under God, indivisible” and her patriotism is challenged. The irony in Melody’s story is her father died protecting freedoms and rights that he and she could not fully enjoy themselves.

There were so many other subtle messages woven into the masterful presentation of this American Girl story. I would love to hear the messages you saw when watching it. If you haven’t yet seen Melody’s story, you should watch it soon!

Were these three messages you missed? Were there others you took from it as well?

You Might Also Like


  • Angela
    November 1, 2016 at 4:19 PM

    I got my 8 year old her first American Girl doll for her birthday in August. She is so attached to that doll. I am eager to get her the Melody Ellison doll, so we can both learn more about her life.

  • Rebecca Bryant
    November 1, 2016 at 7:05 PM

    As agirl who grew up with 6 brothers then had a son i really have never been up to date on American girl happenings. I do think they are pretty dolls thought. Thanks for this unique look.
    Rebecca Bryant would like you to check out…Preparing For Cold and Flu SeasonMy Profile

  • Ashley
    November 1, 2016 at 7:07 PM

    We adore Melody and her story. My daughter has read all the books and seen the movie a few times. I like that you pointed out a few things people might miss.
    Ashley would like you to check out…Disney Dream Pirate Night!My Profile

  • Kerri
    November 1, 2016 at 7:48 PM

    My girls and I also watched Melody’s movie. There were a lot of times that we paused and talked and paused and cried. An emotional must see!
    Kerri would like you to check out…Mother Daughter Love with Auli’i Cravalho at our #Moana InterviewMy Profile

  • Rosey
    November 1, 2016 at 9:24 PM

    It is a wonderful way to teach lessons that will stick. We missed the American Girl phase with my daughter, I’m hoping we won’t skip it with my granddaughter. 🙂

  • Leave a Reply